Both are starved
On 12 March 1807 William Hyde Wollaston read a short paper to the Royal Society called "On Fairy-rings". He was the society's secretary and a chemist. A few years earlier he had found palladium and rhodium. The paper is seven pages long. He begins by declining to review anyone else's theory and says he will just report what he saw "during a few years residence in the country". I read it in the Philosophical Transactions OCR at jimclifford.ca.
What he saw. A fairy ring is a circle of darker grass in an old pasture. Wollaston noticed that the mushrooms on such a ring are always on its outer edge. On one ring the dark grass was twelve or fourteen inches wide, and the mushrooms stood in a band four or five inches wide just outside it. A second kind of fungus did the same thing. He guessed that a fungus uses up something in the soil, "some peculiar pabulum", and can't fruit on the same ground a second time. The next year's crop then has to stand a little further out. Its old ground lies behind it and fresh ground lies ahead, so the ring can only go one way. The grass inside goes dark and rank because the dead fungus rots into it. Where the fungi are actually standing, the grass is "for a while destroyed". That gives the three bands everyone has seen, from the centre out: ordinary grass, dark grass, a bare brown strip with mushrooms on it, and then the untouched field.
He dug down and found that the white "spawn", the mycelium, makes a wave shape in section. Its inner side slopes up towards the surface and its outer side is nearly vertical, "a wave proceeding from the centre outwards". He marked several rings with cuts in the turf three or four years running. They moved outward by anything from eight inches to two feet a year.
None of this was entirely new. William Withering had already blamed one agaric, the champignon now called Marasmius oreades, though he hadn't watched any ring grow. James Hutton had watched arcs of dark grass on Arthur's Seat in Edinburgh without ever seeing a fungus on them. He called them "a piece of natural history worth recording, and for which, a theory is wanting." Hutton did get one thing out of the shapes alone, though. The arcs he saw over successive years were "never inscribed but always circumscribed": a later arc always lay outside an earlier one, never inside it. So the circles had to be growing. You can read the direction of time off a curve if you know that curves only ever bulge outward.
The test. What makes the paper more than a good guess is one paragraph near the end. If a ring is a front moving into ground it then leaves exhausted, two rings that meet can't pass through each other. Each is walking into the other's spent soil. Wollaston looked for this, and found it:
Whenever two adjacent circles are found to interfere, they not only do not cross each other, but both circles are invariably obliterated between the points of contact: at least in more than twenty cases, I have seen no one instance to the contrary. The exhaustion occasioned by each obstructs the progress of the other, and both are starved.
Lightning, moles, grubs and dancing don't predict this. Starvation does, and he checked it more than twenty times. The two rings fuse into one figure shaped like a figure eight with the waist rubbed out. After that the merged ring keeps growing outward as a single, lumpier curve. He adds one case where a ring of puffballs met a ring of mushrooms, and they did not cross either, which suggests the two species live on the same thing. He is careful to say he saw it only once.
He also saw a tree in the way. The ring parted around it, each side "passing obliquely" into the soil beyond the trunk, so the circle became kidney-shaped. He expected the two ends to join up behind the tree within a year or two. He tried one experiment to find out how long spent ground takes to recover. He cut a groove across a mushroom ring and planted spawn from the edge near the centre, and nothing grew. He then left the country and handed the question on to "those who are more favourably circumstanced".
How slow. What Wollaston described is what is now called an excitable medium. Something sweeps through, uses the ground up and can't come back until the ground recovers. Grass fires behave this way, and so do the chemical waves in a Belousov–Zhabotinsky dish and the electrical waves in heart muscle. Colliding waves in all of them annihilate exactly as his rings did, for his reason. What is odd about fairy rings is the speed. A ring moves a few inches to a couple of feet a year, so it is the same kind of wave as a flame front, slowed down about a million times.
The slowness means a ring can be very old. In 1917 H. L. Shantz and R. L. Piemeisel published a long study of rings on the dry grasslands of eastern Colorado. A 1918 review in the Botanical Gazette summarises it. There a ring might advance 30–60 cm in a wet year and hardly at all in a dry one, and from those rates they put a few of the largest at 400 to 600 years old. They attributed the dark grass to nitrogen the fungus releases as it breaks down organic matter and as its own threads decay. They put the dead band mainly down to drought, because the dense mycelium keeps water out of the soil. That is a different mechanism from Wollaston's "pabulum", but his prediction didn't depend on what exactly gets used up, only on something getting used up. A ring near Belfort in eastern France, of Infundibulicybe geotropa, is reported at about 600 m across and over seven hundred years old. A front that slow, running outward since the thirteenth century is presumably still one fungus. Its middle has long since gone, and only the edge is alive.
The piece A kidney round a tree lets you start rings on a lawn and watch them meet. It is a toy, a grid of soil that is fresh, fed on or spent, but it does what Wollaston's twenty cases did.